Rick Sherlund, the veteran Wall Street analyst who has covered Microsoft since it went public, this morning reduced his earnings estimates for the company by 4 percent for the upcoming calendar year, saying Windows 8 isn’t getting as much support as it needs from computer makers.

The report comes as Microsoft prepares for its annual meeting of shareholders later this morning in Bellevue, Wash. Sherlund’s outlook counters the positive momentum that Microsoft sought to create yesterday as it reported 40 million Windows 8 licenses sold since the Oct. 26 launch.

Sherlund, an analyst with Nomura Equity Research, writes, “Windows 8 is off to an awkward launch, with PC vendors slow to bring out their new form factors (tablets and Ultrabook touch devices), Windows 8 has learning curve requirements and abundant bad press on the dual interfaces, and there is an ongoing substitution of tablets for PCs with Microsoft and partners not yet up to scale with Windows 8 based tablets and hybrid devices.”

He says the reduction in his estimate reflects “recent PC data points out of Asia and the presumption that traditional PC units are in secular decline and the ramp of Windows 8 needs some time.”

However, he continues to rate Microsoft shares a “buy” and notes, “We suspect that the shares of Microsoft already reflect much of the bad news. We think investors that can have a thick skin through the awkward quarter or two of the Windows 8 transition will likely see better traction ahead.”

Sherlund now expects the company to post earnings per share of $3.15 in calendar year 2013, compared with the average Wall Street estimate of $3.23. Excluding the impact of revenue deferrals from the Windows 8 launch, Sherlund’s estimate is $2.95 for 2013, up about 8.5 percent from 2012.

He writes, “Street numbers seem to be widely scattered, with a number that appear too high, and we think will need to come down unless there is strong traction for Windows 8 in the second month following its launch on October 26th.”

A report on Nov. 16 by longtime Microsoft watcher Paul Thurrott said Windows 8 sales were well below Microsoft’s internal projections, citing an anonymous source.

GeekWire will be covering Microsoft’s shareholder meeting this morning — check back for details.

Like what you're reading? Subscribe to GeekWire's free newsletters to catch every headline


  • Guest

    As suspected, the 40 million W8 licenses, not users, were likely nothing more than a PR spin by MSFT for the upcoming annual shareholders meeting today. Enough to save Ballmers head and then reality will kick in.

    • Guest

      Yeah, you’re right. Those people from multi-billion mutual funds with hundreds of millions riding on MS probably got snowed by something that was obvious to you.

  • http://www.christopherbudd.com Christopher Budd

    I think the interesting thing is these comments echo what Thurrott said people were saying. Specifically: “Windows 8 isn’t getting as much support as it needs from computer makers.”

  • guest

    There is also the issue that TV shows that were recorded 6 months ago are pitching Windows 7, with commercials for the show pitching Windows 8. It’s very confusing.

  • Alfiejr

    no way 40 million consumers have bought a W8 upgrade/new PC. and businesses take mach longer to prepare for such updates, if any. MS is no doubt lumping acutal and “estimated” 2012 sales to OEM’s into one vapor hype number. and then put it into the web rumor zone via a deny-able remark by a “senior exec.”

    sucker bait.

    • guest

      They didn’t say 40M consumers had. And the remark was by the CFO of Windows and very much on the record. So not “deny-able” at all.

      • Alfiejr

        it’s called “stuffing the channel” – licenses contracted by the OEM’s but not yet delivered on PC’s to real people.

        • Guest

          No, it’s called you making statements which were false.

Job Listings on GeekWork