It must have pretty exciting for jurors in Salt Lake City to see Bill Gates arrive to testify in Novell’s antitrust case against Microsoft.

That was Monday. By yesterday the thrill was gone, apparently replaced with the realization that they’re deciding a case based on events that took place more than 15 years ago, involving versions of software that nobody uses anymore.

Gates, meanwhile, was back in fighting form — or at least a 56-year-old approximation of it.

That’s the impression left by this Associated Press report from the scene, as Gates faced cross-examination from Novell’s lawyer over claims that Microsoft used the market power of Windows 95 to make decisions that damaged WordPerfect, then a main a competitor to Microsoft Word.

On Tuesday, Gates shot back that Word was “far superior” to WordPerfect, which was a “bulky, slow, buggy product” that did not integrate well with Windows 95. Gates said his engineers warned it threatened the reliability of future Windows versions.

For hours Tuesday, Gates sparred with Novell’s trial attorney over software terms as jury members yawned in boredom.

“He’s not an easy witness,” said Novell attorney Jeffrey Johnson.

Gates was legendary for his behavior during a deposition conducted by David Boies during the company’s landmark U.S. antitrust case.

The Novell case, filed in 2004, has been through an extended series of twists and turns, and was revived by an appeals court in May.

Also see this Bloomberg News report for more details from the courtroom.

Like what you're reading? Subscribe to GeekWire's free newsletters to catch every headline


  • Mike Borozdin

    Gates should give Novell Windows 95 source code as a settlement.

    • Anonymous

      I say no. Windows belongs to Microsoft, and that shouldn’t change. Windows source code is also kept to Microsoft only. This case is too old. Besides, WordPerfect is long gone.

  • Craig O

    I served on a jury in a patent case. The reality is that the average juror is so stupid they can’t follow along and the attorneys know it as well. The result is attorneys talking to you like you are a five year old. A really slow five year old at that. 

  • Sourav Dey

    Let the war begin again. It’s Bill Gates, he better knows how to beat.

Job Listings on GeekWork