The law is starting to catch up to an undeniable reality of modern technology — recognizing that smartphones are not just devices unto themselves but rather portals to a much larger world.
Reacting to a decision of the state’s Supreme Court, the California legislature passed a bill that will require police to get a warrant before searching “information in a portable electronic device” carried by a person who’s been arrested.
The bill states that it does not mean to curtail the ability of law enforcement to rely upon “established exceptions to the warrant requirement.”
Instead, the legislation is intended to trump the California Supreme Court’s decision in People v. Diaz. I wrote about that case in an earlier guest post on GeekWire. Purporting to interpret the US Constitution, the court had found a warrantless search of a suspect’s phone was permitted because it fell under an exception to the normal warrant requirement — the exception for searches “incident to a lawful custodial arrest.”
Amazingly, the bill rebuffing the court is short and easy to understand. And it pinpoints exactly the issue California’s high court missed: cell phones are not “incidental” to a person, like a pack of cigarettes or items you might carry in your jeans or a shirt pocket. Rather, as the legislation states, phones can be a link to a potentially unlimited trove of personal information about a suspect:
“These devices are capable of and encourage the storing of an almost limitless amount of personal and private information. Commonly linked to the Internet, these devices are used to access personal and business information and databases that reside in computers and servers located anywhere in the world.”
That’s exactly up to date. Maybe the justices on the California high court need to buy new phones!
Attorney William Carleton is a member of McNaul Ebel Nawrot & Helgren PLLC, a Seattle law firm. He works with startups and emerging tech companies, their founders and investors.
He posts regularly about tech-related legal issues on his blog.
Also By William Carleton
- Arts People Don’t Use Foursquare. Do They?
- Amazon and California: How Sausage Gets Made
- Grading the Computer’s Sports Reporting