Editor’s Note: This post was originally published on Seattle 2.0, and imported to GeekWire as part of our acquisition of Seattle 2.0 and its archival content. For more background, see this post.

By David Aronchick

We are all narcissistic whores. The Interweb has done it to us; it’s impossible not to stare into the pond when there is nowhere else to look. As a result, we spend far too much time watching river of social data for every mere mention of something that we care about or, worse, gazing at our navel because no one is talking about us. So we listen, and talk, and every so often it pays off in just a little bit of an echo to make us feel like someone cares if we live or die. So is this a screed against new media? Not at all. There is a point to all this, and not only is it valuable for you, it’s crucial for your startup.

One of the biggest failures you can make for your company is adopting the Field of Dreams approach to marketing – I promise if you build it, people will not come. Ever. If this thought enters your mind for even a second, whatever you are planning to do will fail. Marketing your startup is a daily, brutal grind, but that’s your only chance of ever having any success. Assuming you would like to win, how do you get there?

The first step is identifying your goal. Simple volume does not add much – it is important to be out there, but just noise does not really forward the conversation. To steal from Scrum, you must identify not just what you are going to do, but how you will measure the success of your efforts. There are a thousand ways to reach out, if you try to do them all without a goal in mind, you will just spin your wheels. Here are some things to think about:
  • What’s the purpose of the channel you’re developing? Blog posts are great for subscribers and long lasting positions, and semi regular updates, twitter accounts for one-to-one communication, and facebook posts somewhere in between.
  • What does success look like for a given set of work? If you’re looking for direct traffic wins, that may look very differently than if you are simply trying to engage your users. One is all about the short term wins (retweets, facebook likes, emails), the other is measured only after the search engines have had a chance to update their indexes (SEO, unique domains, etc).
  • How long is your window for engagement? Being responsive to customers wins loyalty, and more users via word of mouth but is extremely short term. Miss a day, and you will miss lots of opportunities. Deep links, in-bound traffic and conversions are long slow burns; they take commitment but it is not the kind of thing that will be won or lost on a days postings.

There are lots more stats – the important thing here is thinking through up front what matters for you and your business.

Second, you need need to be committed to the long term. These efforts are neither easy nor instantaneous – a lot of really great metrics can take literally months to sort out. For example, one of the goals of our blog was to highlight the hundreds of thousands of sound bites that we have on the site that do not get as much traffic as the keyword research would suggest. We’ve started a process to highlight this content, but we’re not going to be able to measure the success until the search tools all catch up with this new content, and we can measure fun stats like inbound links, unique domains and page rank. Pick your stats and put them up on the wall. You can check them as much as you want, but do not expect to get there overnight.
Finally, while there are lots of great leaders out there in the social Web, do not expect to follow their playbook and achieve instant success. Smart Bear and Chris Brogan have had a great debate recently about how to have a successful blog strategy. There are some fantastic nuggets in there, but they also are more than a little anomalous; they have huge followings because they were successful elsewhere, and brought that audience to their current communications. Ditto with Jeff Atwood and Joel Spolsky starting the wonderful StackExchange; they simply could not have gotten as far as fast if they had not spent ten years building their own audiences on their own sites and followings. To craft your own strategy, here are some items to think about:
  • Frequency – more is almost always better, and regularity counts. If you are going to engage, commit.
  • Content – There’s absolutely no harm in being a complete sell-out in these mediums, take every chance to talk about yourself you can. But, at the same time, people are not going to share unless it means something to them – help your readers and followers see themselves in your writings and they will want to connect and share even more.
  • Length – It can vary wildly, but when all else fails, see the content point above. You could write a six word story or a four thousand word treatise, but all that matters is if your users care. Tweets and facebooks have length as well; whether or not they are simple two word responses, or URLs and detailed content, do not just think about blogs when it comes to getting your message out.
  • Resourcing – I highly recommend that it is someone’s full time job to check all your accounts and do it on a daily basis. A part-timer could work, but it is one of those things that quickly can fall by the way-side when meetings and other deliverables pop up. Nothing sticks out as a sore thumb more than a blog or a social account that has not been updated in months.

The nice part about this is that there is no single formula that will work – on this, I completely agree with Jason Cohen. You should try a thousand things, some will work and some will not, but you will have a presence and that matters. Marketing will be far more hit and miss than other areas of your business, but the most important thing is to dive in. Because the bigger the success or failure, the more information you will get about your profile in the world, whether about your site, your company or you. In this case, it is not just ok to be self-centered, it is a recipe for success.

Like what you're reading? Subscribe to GeekWire's free newsletters to catch every headline

Job Listings on GeekWork

Find more jobs on GeekWork. Employers, post a job here.