Microsoft: Google declined invite to bid together on Novell patents

Brad Smith, Microsoft general counsel

The war of words is escalating quickly between Microsoft and Google over patents and Android.

Microsoft’s general counsel responded this afternoon to a withering blog post from his Google counterpart that accused the Redmond company of getting in bed with Apple to use questionable patents to undermine Google’s Android mobile operating system.

Posted Microsoft’s Brad Smith on Twitter: “Google says we bought Novell patents to keep them from Google. Really? We asked them to bid jointly with us. They said no.”

That was a reference to an effort by a consortium led by Microsoft to acquire Novell’s patents. They ultimately ended up entering into a licensing deal instead, after the Department of Justice raised objections.

In his blog post earlier today, Google’s David Drummond cited the Novell patent bid as one example of “a hostile, organized campaign against Android by Microsoft, Oracle, Apple and other companies, waged through bogus patents.” He also pointed to Microsoft’s patent lawsuits against Android device makers, and its broader effort to extract patent royalties on Android devices.

Here’s an email that, according to Microsoft, shows Google turning down the invitation. (Click to enlarge.)

  • Guest

    Another embarrassing episode for Google.

  • Anonymous

    I think there is an ethical reason why Google didn’t want to buy patents with some of the worst patent players in the industry. Google didn’t want bloody hands.

    • Axel

      What an Epic PR Fail. Google decided to outsmart MS and received massive pownage.

      Now it cries about unfair bussines and patents trying to shift public attention from it`s fail. 

    • Bob

      Is that why they indicated their desire to be considered in future bids?

      • Anonymous

        I wasn’t aware that they wanted to be included as partners with the other 3 or 4, or even with Microsoft to bid jointly on patents.  Do you have a reference?

        • Bob

          “But I appreciate you flagging it, and we’re *open to discussing similar opportunities in the future*”

    • Bob

      Is that why they indicated their desire to be considered in future bids?